Edgy Christian Fiction

In Christian fiction, how do we balance keeping the message strong/not watering it down while still wanting to reach readers beyond Christian bookstores or churches?

Thank you Carrie for a great question.

This has been an ongoing discussion ever since Christian Fiction became a significant part of the publishing landscape in the late 70s – early 80s.

The issue as it has been presented to me is “Why can’t there be ‘edgy’ Christian fiction?”

My answer stays the same and comes in the form of a couple return questions. “How does one define ‘edgy’?” And “Who defines it?”

There are three main areas of dispute: Sex, Language, and Violence.

For some readers any sort of sexual tension, even sensuality is off limits. Even the description of a woman or man’s body could have a limit. But for others the threshold is much different. They think books that would get a PG-13 rating or even R are acceptable. Bedroom scenes, body part descriptions, etc. are all fair game.

For some readers any sort of coarse language is off limits. But for others they say that the lack of coarse language is unrealistic and therefore it should be used all the time. But that begs the question of what constitutes “coarse”? (In movie ratings, the use of the f-bomb as an expletive, between one and three times, will be enough for the PG-13 rating. But, according to this article, if it is used as a verb, one time, the movie will receive an R rating.)

As for violence? How much “blood splatter” is considered too much? What about description of the aftermath of a terrible car accident? What about head shots by a gun? What about war novels? What about suspense or thriller novels? Should Christian fiction instead all be “cozy mystery” where you don’t see the dead body?

I love how one Christian writer uses “language” without using it. In his recent novel Flags Out Front , Douglas Wilson has a scene on page 181 where it reads, “He dumped out two buckets of cuss words onto the carpet, and then spent a good ten minutes kicking them around the room with his cowboy boots.”

In that example, there is obvious coarse language being used but I didn’t have to read the words. And the description of the tirade is funny but still gets the point across without diving into the cesspool of offensive language.

There is a market for clean fiction. There is no disputing that.
The problem is defining “clean.”

I’ll let you draw your own conclusions from my thoughts. Feel free to discuss below.

Please read some of our other posts on the topic:

Real Life is Edgy – Dan Balow

Eat, Drink, and be Merry – Tamela Hancock Murray

What Makes a Christian Book Christian – Part 1 – Karen Ball

What Makes a Christian Book Christian – Part 2 – Karen Ball

What Makes a Christian Book Christian – Part 3 – Karen Ball

Leave a Comment

Time to Play!

As I was considering what to write for this week’s blog, I realized I needed a break from all the seriousness of the last few weeks. Not that I don’t love the “conversations” and insights everyone has shared. But, at the core, I’m a golden-retriever kinda gal, and I gots …

Read More

Choosing Your Words Wisely, Part 2

Here are some of my all-time favorite jokes: To get to the other side. Hugh and only Hugh can stamp out florist friars. Silly Rabbi, kicks are for Trids! Oh, my baking yak! Minnie was called, but Chew was frozen. I better run this through again! Give me a couple …

Read More

Choosing Your Words Wisely, Part 1

There are a number of reasons for the apparent decrease in reading in the world, from attention-span changes brought on by reader’s addiction to various “screens” to climate change. But it might simply be a vocabulary problem. The first time this concept came to me was about 25 years ago …

Read More

Writing the Deeper Story

I realize this will probably date me, but I sincerely enjoyed a popular radio feature by Paul Harvey called, “The Rest of the Story.” I assume some reading this post today also remember it. For generations, the venerable radio commentator, who passed away in 2009 at the age of 90, …

Read More

Go Ahead: Take an Online Break

Wow, what great sites you all shared. Thanks so much for letting us in on your online breaks. So here are the places I like to go when I need a break. Some are great for just a few minutes, some give a nice long break. But they’re all great …

Read More

Easily Entertained

Recently my husband, daughter, and I had dinner with my parents at King’s Barbeque in Petersburg, Virginia. My paternal grandfather discovered this restaurant in the 1950s and it is still one of our family’s favorite places. Since it was near Christmas, they displayed a unique decoration – a pig wearing …

Read More

New Year, New First Lines!

Are you as stunned as I am that we’re already weeks into 2017? I figure the beginning of an all-new year is a great time to share our all-new first lines! I love seeing what you all are working on, so jump in and share the first line—and ONLY the …

Read More

The Seeds of Great Ideas

Thanks so much for sharing your tips and sources for ideas last week. What fun to read your thoughts and insights. I’d invite you all to review those comments from time to time, considering if one or more of them might not help you expand the ways you develop ideas. …

Read More