Book Proposals

Do You Really Want to Change Our Minds?

Agents know how difficult it is to break in to publishing, to keep your stride as a midlist author, and to stay on top once you’re there. We realize where you’re coming from when you send us something we say we don’t represent, thinking it’s so wonderful we might change our minds. Maybe it is that wonderful. Maybe we might change our minds.

But is that what you really want?

Let’s look at two diametrically different examples to see why you might not want representation from certain agents.

Children’s Books:

I loved reading books to both of my girls when they were growing up. I can read Fox in Sox aloud at warp speed! But I don’t actively seek to represent children’s book authors. I do represent children’s books for authors who are already my clients. But if you’re a new children’s book author, not already my client, and are trying to break in to this competitive place, realize that I have very few strong contacts in the children’s book market. Most of the ones I do have focus on Christian books. So even if I love your general market children’s picture book, what editors would I be able to pursue for you?

Note that in both the general and Christian markets, a well-known author writing for adults will often publish a children’s book. Editors know that the adults who buy books for the children in their lives will gravitate to a name they already know and like. Not only that, but celebrities with no prior publishing experience write for children, creating more competition for non-celebrity authors who only write children’s books. So these markets are hard to tap into even under the best circumstances. If you don’t already have solid contacts yourself for the agent to pursue on your behalf, then you especially don’t need an agent with only a few contacts of his representing you, no matter how much the agent loves your book.


At the other extreme, sometimes authors will submit, if not outright erotica, books with vivid and unapologetic sexual content. No one in my office will ever know if your novel is so wonderful it could change our minds because once we understand the content, we won’t read it. Period.

Look at it this way: say you know an auto mechanic specializing in restoring vintage automobiles. He should be a whiz at understanding your 2017 Lincoln Continental, right? After all, they are both cars, with four tires and an engine. They both transport people from Point A to Point B.

But the restoration mechanic doesn’t have a computer to diagnose problems because he doesn’t need one. He doesn’t have the contacts to buy new Lincoln parts through the best channels, nor does he possess the latest information about your new vehicle warranty. He may love your new baby, and he might be able to apply some of his knowledge of vintage vehicles to your car, but he simply doesn’t have the same data or resources you’ll find at the Lincoln dealership, where they both know and love your car.

Back to publishing, why would you want to trust your work to an agent who doesn’t have the right contacts, robust interest in your type of book, and resources, to maximize your success? The expression, “Any agent is better than no agent,” simply isn’t true. An agent who’s unquestionably qualified and wonderful at representing one type of book, or a certain category of books, isn’t always at her best representing a different category requiring a completely different set of contacts, data, and experience. The more time you spend finding an agent who’s a right fit for you before you submit, the less of your time you’ll waste, and the less likely you’ll find your submissions deleted with no response.

Your turn:

How many agents did you submit to before finding acceptance?

If you’re in the processing of deciding how and where to submit, how will you research agents?



Leave a Comment

The Ambitious Author

Recently my office received an unsolicited submission from an author unfamiliar to us. Of course, this is not unusual. But here is a list of what is unusual: The submission was openly cc’ed to 185 agents. The author sent writing samples for 28 books. The author said she wants to …

Read More

Why Write a Synopsis?

Attention all novelists! I get it. I understand how difficult it is to write a synopsis. And yet, every fiction book proposal must have a synopsis. Everyone who teaches on the book proposal says you need one. But why? Those two to three single-spaced pages of agony will never be …

Read More

WHAT Were They Thinking??

You know, one of the things I’ve learned since becoming an agent is that people have an odd sense of what’s appropriate. Happily, quite a lot of what I receive is well prepared and enjoyable to read. But I’d have to say that anywhere from a fourth to even, on …

Read More

Is Your Writing Controlled by Fate?

I was going to title this blog post something along the lines of “Calvinist vs. Arminian Authors,” or “Predestination vs. Free Will in Publishing,” but these titles inferred an entirely different angle than I intended. Every author believes their book, if published and promoted enough has the potential to sell …

Read More

How Self-Publishing Has Changed Authors

As a literary agent, not a day goes by when I don’t encounter the changes in thinking from authors caused by the expansion and availability of self-publishing. It’s understandable, because there are over twice as many books self-published every year in the United States than are published by traditional publishers. …

Read More

A Roundup of Some Queries

Periodically we try to show you some of the more unusual things we receive, unsolicited, by our agency. These are by no means all of them (not exhaustive…just exhausting). Just a few to help those who read this blog avoid the same mistakes. Disclaimer: We do not suggest that any of …

Read More

2017 Christian Writers Market Guide Now Online!

The 2017 edition of The Christian Writers Market Guide is officially available in print and ebook (paperback $22.99, ebook $9.99). Check your favorite bookstore or online retailer for a copy. Make sure you have a copy of this book in your arsenal! We are also very excited to announce that all the content …

Read More

Christian Criticism

Most agents to the Christian publishing world represent a variety of authors from a wide spectrum of theological thought, so we understandably have a little more forgiving attitude than others about differences between fellow believers. There is one type of book I have always felt uncomfortable representing…one which criticizes a …

Read More